Showing posts with label Decision-Making. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Decision-Making. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

9-8-10 Are You A Bad Executive?

I read a blog entry today…. On BNET, by Steve Tobak about the “7 signs you may be a bad manager”. I recommend that you read the article. You can find it here.

7 Signs You May Be a Bad Manager by Steve Tobak.

Be sure to come back. I’ll wait…….

While I won’t recreate Tobak’s list here, I would like to draw a couple of parallels with the Executive Skills and Traits model that I’ve relentlessly discussed on this blog (12-30-09 Morphing to a Model).

For example, one to the signs mentioned by Tobak is that your “allies are distancing themselves from you”. One of the Communication Skills that I’ve discussed on several occasions is the need for the new/aspiring executive to create and maintain a network (1-4-10 Let's Talk). One of the members in your network should absolutely be the person you turn to for reality checks. For me, that was my executive coach. I’ve talked about this role in the past (2-8-10 Shoulda Told Me #6). Let’s face it, if you are developing into a bad executive, it isn’t happening overnight. There are indications that other people see as it is happening. So your executive coach or sounding board or whatever you choose to call it has to be the person that is willing and able to give you the figurative slap upside the head when you are being an ass.

Another sign discussed by Tobak that you are a bad manager is that “your decision-making is compromised”. Being decisive is a critical Execution Skill for the executive (1-13-10 Execution Skills -- Now go DO something!). Does every decision you make lately seem to turn into crap? And more importantly, have you been able to rationalize each bad outcome? If so, then yes, you are headed down the road of a bad executive. You need to step back and analyze your outcomes -- ask yourself some questions. What key item did I miss leading up to the decision? Did I ignore someone that I should’ve listened to? Did I not get the right people involved? And as important, you can’t let a few poor decisions freeze you from future action.

Take some time to analyze your performance, your interactions, and your organization. Get feedback. Then take action so that you aren’t one of those bad executives that everyone loves to talk about.

Cheers!

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

8-17-10 Discovering Limits

One of my nieces is visiting this week (love you, Kaitlyn!). She just turned 21. Ahhh to be young….. Actually, now that I think about it, not really. But it does bring back memories of discovering my limits when I was around that age.

Things like: How much autonomy do I really have from my parents? How much can I drink? How much studying do I really need to do for that test? How much can I work and still be able to go to school? At that age, there are all sorts of limits to be discovered.

As a new executive, you have a similar road to travel on discovering your limits. Of course, if you are an executive, you have already spent a fair amount of time defining and discovering the limits around your career. But as you transition to the executive payroll, there are new limits to discover.

For example, you will have to discover how much authority you actually have. Intuitively you know that you are granted additional authorities when you are promoted. The problem is…. How much? Unfortunately you will only discover the answer to this question by trial and error. Yes, you can define authority limits with your boss up front. But believe me, things change. You can make a decision one day that you believe is wholly within the limits of your authority…. Only to be chastised by your boss the next day for doing it. The limits probably didn’t shift overnight. Instead you and your boss didn’t clearly delineate all limits. Not surprising, as it would be impossible to do.

You will find many more instances of defining limits as you progress in your executive career. Fortunately, unlike the 21 year old discovering the limits of alcohol, you won’t likely face a life-threatening situation. However, you will face many career-threatening situations.

My advice? Be deliberate. Think your choices through. Don’t back away from the perceived limit. But don’t barge ahead with your head down and your senses shut off.

Cheers!

Monday, August 9, 2010

8-9-10 The Decider

Most executives don’t consider their job title to be “The Decider”. And that is a mistake. Why? Because most executives would tell you, if you asked how decisions are made in their company, that it is a group effort. Remember, the model for Executive Skills and Traits defines decisiveness as one of the important execution skills that an executive will need (12-30-09 Morphing to a Model and 1-13-10 Execution Skills -- Now go DO something!).

One of my survey participants had an interesting take on the whole “decider” role that the executive should play. He said,

“Effectiveness at being a leader can by crystallized on those big-deal moments: the pitch is over, the options are up there, sides are drawn. Everyone is looking at the decision-maker -- ‘the decider‘.”

Yes, I know. In the past I have talked about the need for the executive to “spread around” the decision-making. I’m not backing away from that. As an executive, you have to know what level is the appropriate level for making a decision. Many times that level will be one of your staff members.

There are times, however, when YOU will be the decision maker. That is what my survey participant was talking about. You have to take the information that you have, check your gut, take a deep breath, and make the damn decision.

It is interesting how many times that I’ve seen an executive actually back away from one of those big-deal moments. Perhaps they do this by delegating a decision that should not be. Or they “make a decision” by not actually deciding anything (putting their avoidance technique to work). Or they let the group make the decision. Or they kick it upstairs to be made.

Whatever the method, by backing away, the executive becomes less effective. Not only for the current decision, but also for future ones. If your boss or peers or staff watched you back away from one big-deal moment, how likely are they to come back to you the next time? Why bother, if you can’t make a decision!?

So remember, as an executive you ARE expected to make decisions. Step up. You can do it.

Cheers!

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

7-28-10 Is It Better To Beg Forgiveness?

Here’s an interesting question….. Is it better to beg forgiveness or to ask permission? Hmmmmm…..

Guess that depends on the situation, of course. But in the business world, I learned early on that it is better to take action and then beg forgiveness if something goes awry.

Oh sure, there are times that it is absolutely mandatory that you ask permission. Like when you are about to commit the company to a multi-billion dollar contract, well then, you should probably ask a couple of people if it is okay. There is a line here that you must not cross…. And that line will vary depending on your boss of the moment, your situation, your company, etc.

But, for most of the day-to-day business activities, I never really had much luck with asking permission. It gives people the opportunity to delay your actions -- even when their agreement wasn’t really needed. It also gives people the opportunity to torpedo your actions -- if it is something they don’t want. Or, heaven forbid, it gives someone the opportunity to say no. And if that someone is your boss, you can consider the door to be firmly shut to your idea. No amount of finagling will get you back to yes.

My policy is to assume that I have the authority (and responsibility) to do something until someone (usually my boss) tells me different. Have I screwed up with that attitude? Occasionally, yes. Hence the idea of begging forgiveness. It is real easy to say, “I’m sorry, but I thought that was my responsibility. I’ll not do that again”.

Interestingly, people (my boss, specifically) have always been willing to accept that and we move on.

Here’s something even more interesting. I’ve gotten feedback in the past that I was rated highly in evaluations because of my willingness to take the initiative, make a decision, and implement a plan. If I hadn’t assumed the appropriate authority, that would have never happened.

So remember, you are an executive. And you are in charge. Act like it.

Cheers!

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

7-14-10 On Being Decisive

One of the execution skills in the Executive Skills/Traits model involves being decisive (12-30-09 Morphing to a Model and 1-13-10 Execution Skills -- Now go DO something!).

One of my survey participants had an interesting take on this skill. He said, “Many/most times decisions are elevated due to lack of a clear cut ‘answer‘. Being able to listen to opposing arguments and make a decision is critical to exec leadership. If it was easy, the team would have already decided.”

If you haven’t figured it out yet, being an executive ain’t easy.

As an executive, you no longer get to make the easy decisions -- if you’ve delegated appropriately. The easy decisions are made by your staff or your managers. That means you get stuck with the hard decisions.

And as my survey participant indicated, in order to make those hard decisions you have to weigh the information and the opposing arguments. Fairly and impartially. The “fair” part is easy for most executives. The “impartial” part usually isn’t.

Why? Because we all have a past or history. And that can impact our analysis and decision-making. In order to be a successful executive, you have to recognize your past and your biases -- then to the extent possible, leave them behind. And if you can’t, you at least need to factor them in to your decision-making process.

Of course, once the decision is made, then it has to be implemented. But that’s another post……

Cheers!

Monday, May 3, 2010

5-3-10 It Is Okay to Change Your Mind

In past entries in this blog, I’ve talked some about finding your passion and expecting change in your career (3-19-10 A Couple of Things to Consider and 3-15-10 Do Overs? and 3-10-10 Shoulda Told Me #8 and 12-9-09 Work for Free??). But a conversation today with my niece (thanks Kaitlyn! Love you.) has me thinking some more about the topic.

Why is it that we expect our 18 to 20 year olds to know what they want to do for the rest of their work life -- when they don’t usually even know at this point what their passion in life is? And yet, despite this, our universities ask them to pick a major and then proceed through their training and education with a single-minded focus of someone that has it all figured out.

Heck, I’m 50-something and I STILL don’t have it figured out! And I’ve been through 3 disparate degrees, along with 25 or so years of career. Seems to me that we are handicapping our next generation with this educational attitude.

And it goes beyond that. As an executive, I think that we are often handicapping our new hires by forcing them to apply for a specific job just to get their foot in the darned door. Yes, I realize that you have to match specific educational background with the specific job openings that you have. And at an entry-level position, you are often looking for those college grads that have the best GPA. But I would contend that it is a bit short-sighted. By limiting your selection based on GPA or on major, you are likely missing some VERY good candidates. Heck, one of my best business analysts had a history degree. And one of my best program managers was a fighter pilot. Not what most hiring executives would’ve looked for, I’m sure.

And then once they are working for us, all to often, we don’t take the time to learn about their varied interests or give them the chance to try new and different things in the workplace. Again, I contend that is short-sighted. You never truly know what your people are capable of until you give them a wide variety of opportunities. Yes, it might make your job a bit more difficult. But really, as an executive isn’t one of your most important jobs to develop your people? And how can you do that without helping them to discover their passion.

Yeah, with both your new hires and your old hands, you run the risk of making a mistake. You might hire the wrong person or you might put a person in a job or project that they simply can’t do. But that is how we learn. We make mistakes. We change. We adapt.

So whether you are the executive or the new hire, you don’t have to know it all right this minute. You can change your mind --- along with changing your major, your job, or even your career.

Cheers!

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

3-31-10 Think for Yourself

Did you notice in the recent health care legislation vote that not one Republican, in either the House or the Senate, voted for the bill(s)? No, I’m not here to start a debate on the whole health care legislation issue. There are plenty of other political blogs, talking heads, and pols that are gleefully doing that online for you. Instead, I’m here to discuss the whole idea of thinking for yourself.

Given the recent legislation, I find it incredibly hard to believe that not one Republican could agree with the legislation. And that means that at least one of them went against their beliefs in what would be good legislation. To me, that also means that he/she didn’t think for themselves --- that they let other people do their thinking for them.

When it comes to this kind of behavior in the executive ranks, I have a problem with that. Yes, I know, in a previous post I talked about the need sometimes to just shut up and salute smartly (2-1-10 Salute Smartly). But I’ve also talked about the need for the executive to be decisive. In fact, it is the number one skill within the execution function for executives (12-30-09 Morphing to a Model).

As an executive, you are expected to be decisive. And the decisions you will make aren’t typically going to be easy. Hell, if they were easy, someone on down the management chain would have already made the decision. And you can be sure that some of the decisions you make won’t be popular. As I used to tell my guys, that’s okay….. That’s why they issue me the big shoulder pads.

Seriously, you can’t make decisions, particularly on extremely important topics, based on what would be popular or what would curry you favor with your party. You have to make decisions based on: what is right for your company, what is right for your people, and what is right for you.

It is always a balancing act. And sometimes you will be better at it than others. But you have to think it through for yourself and then act appropriately. No hiding behind anyone or any group.

Cheers!

Friday, January 22, 2010

1-22-10 Decisions, decisions.......

I was sitting in a meeting one day. Yep, I used to do that a lot. I mean A LOT. Heck, who am I kidding, that WAS my job --- sitting in meetings. But I digress.

Anyway, the stated purpose of this meeting was to come to a decision on which company we were going to work with on a new work package. All of the appropriate people, the decision makers from the various departments, were in the room. I was the one selected to lead the meeting -- at least from the perspective of giving the presentation that would give the leaders the facts they needed to make the decision. Of course, I had my recommendation -- that is what I was paid to do -- research the possibilities, present the information, and the recommendation. On the surface, it appeared to be a pretty straight-forward meeting. Present the information, debate the various points, and come to a consensus on the way forward.

Man, was I wrong!

We spent the next 2 hours going over the information and debating the issue. Seemed like a pretty normal meeting. Except I kept detecting an odd undercurrent from the guy that was the ultimate influencer in the meeting. I couldn’t quite put my finger on it. But I did observe that anytime someone put up objections to his view, he was quick to bat down (or slap down is probably more illustrative) their statements. Particularly if someone was trying to back an alternative work package or company. Now you have to understand that, for this group, vigorous debate was a normal process for coming to a decision. However, this seemed to go way beyond what was normal.

As the meeting wore on, and one-by-one the concerns or objections were shot down, we ultimately agreed with what the ultimate influencer wanted to do. That is when I noticed the facial expression of the chief influencer. You have seen it before, I’m sure. It was that self-satisfied smug smile. Argh. I finally realized that we had wasted those 2 hours --- not to mention all of the prep time I had put in on this project.

This influencer had his mind set and the decision made before we even walked into the room. The entire meeting was a façade. It was setup to make everyone believe that they had input to the decision. When in fact, it didn’t matter what any of us said during the meeting.

So what’s my point? Well, the point here is….. If you are the decision-maker, and you have already made the decision, say so up front. Don’t create a smoke screen by asking for input. Once people figure out what you are doing, trust me, they won’t be happy.

Some people use this tactic because they are looking for buy-in to their decision. Some people don’t even realize they are doing it. Some people are doing it because they can. It doesn’t really matter for which reason. When you use this kind of tactic, the people around you will begin to mistrust you. They will feel used. And they will feel mislead.

Be upfront with your co-workers. Keep topics and motives out in the open. You will all have a much better working relationship.

Cheers!